WHO IS AN EXPERT WITNESS?
Expert witnesses are specialists with extensive knowledge in a specific field, brought into legal proceedings to provide professional opinions that aid court decisions. These experts can range from medical professionals to forensic specialists and financial analysts. Expert evidence is information or opinion given by an expert in any field that person is specialized in, which comes out to be evidence in any matter. They play a crucial role in enhancing the court’s understanding of technical or specialized issues and their interpretation in a legal context.
LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR EXPERT TESTIMONY
The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) serves as the primary legislation governing expert testimony in India.
- Section 39, BSA: Defines the admissibility of expert opinions.
- Section 40, BSA: Allows facts forming the basis of expert opinions to be considered as relevant evidence.
The Supreme Court has provided guidelines on assessing expert witness credibility, emphasizing the importance of impartiality and professional qualifications. Some Indian courts have adopted the Daubert standard for evaluating scientific evidence. However, the Judges retain significant discretion in weighing the value and credibility of expert testimony in their courtrooms.
TYPES OF CASES REQUIRING EXPERT WITNESSES
Expert witnesses play a critical role in the Indian Legal System and are utilized across a wide spectrum of legal cases in India.
- Criminal Cases: In these, the forensic evidence is interpreted, conduct ballistics analysis, or perform DNA profiling.
- Civil Cases: Expert evidence is frequently required for intellectual property disputes, medical malpractice claims, and environmental damage assessments. Even family law cases benefit from expert input, particularly in child custody evaluations and property valuation during divorces.
- Corporate Litigation: Expert testimony is relied on in financial fraud investigations, valuation disputes, and technology patent conflicts.
RELEVANCE OF EXPERT EVIDENCE
In Ram Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2024 INSC 128], the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as follows:
“If the evidence tendered including that of eyewitnesses do not inspire confidence, the omission to seek ballistic opinion and examination of the ballistic expert may be fatal to the prosecution case.”
- Justices Abhay S. Oka & Ujjal Bhuyan
IMPACT ON CASE OUTCOMES
Expert witnesses can significantly influence case outcomes in the following ways:
- By enhancing the jury or judge’s understanding of complex issues.
- They can strengthen or challenge key evidence, provide scientific backing to legal arguments, and help establish causation in civil cases.
- Expert testimony also assists in determining appropriate damages or compensation.
- Their input can be decisive in close or technically complex cases and may even lead to case settlements before trial.
CHALLENGES & CONTROVERSIES
Despite their importance, the use of expert witnesses is not without challenges and controversies.
- There are often concerns about bias, with experts sometimes perceived as partial to the party hiring them.
- The phenomenon of “hired guns” – experts testifying primarily for financial gain – raises ethical questions.
- Conflicting expert opinions can lead to confusion in the courtroom. Non-expert judges and juries may struggle to assess the credibility of highly technical testimony.
- The high costs associated with expert witnesses can limit access to justice for some litigants.
- Expert unavailability sometimes causes delays in proceedings, and there’s a risk of overreliance on expert testimony in some cases.
Stay tuned for more legal insights